Freedom Debt Relief Complaints: A Comprehensive 2026 Review of Risks and Results

For over two decades, Freedom Debt Relief (now often operating under its parent brand, Achieve) has stood as one of the largest debt settlement companies in the United States. As we navigate the financial landscape of 2026, the company continues to resolve billions in consumer debt. However, a high volume of business naturally brings a high volume of feedback.

freedom-debt-relief-complaints-2026-review

Picture: Getty Images

If you are considering enrolling, understanding the common complaints about Freedom Debt Relief and how the program actually works is vital. This article explores the company’s reputation, historical legal challenges, and whether its "settlement over consolidation" approach is safe for your wallet in 2026.

What is Freedom Debt Relief?

Freedom Debt Relief is a debt settlement provider that negotiates with creditors to reduce the total balance you owe. Unlike a debt consolidation loan, where you pay off your creditors immediately with borrowed money, debt settlement involves stopping payments to your creditors and instead depositing that money into a "dedicated account." Once that account grows, Freedom's negotiators approach your creditors with a lump-sum settlement offer.

2026 Snapshot:

Minimum Debt Required: $7,500
Typical Fees: 15% to 25% of the enrolled debt.
Average Timeline: 24 to 48 months.
Accreditations: A+ Rating with the Better Business Bureau (BBB), member of the American Fair Credit Council (AFCC).

Common Freedom Debt Relief Complaints in 2026

While the company maintains high ratings on platforms like Trustpilot (averaging 4.6/5 stars), a look at the critical reviews reveals consistent patterns. Most Freedom Debt Relief complaints fall into three categories:

1. The Impact on Credit Scores

The most frequent complaint isn't about the company's service, but the nature of debt settlement itself. To settle a debt, you must stop paying the creditor. This leads to:

Delinquency marks on your credit report.
Aggressive collection calls and letters.
A significant drop in your credit score can take years to recover.

2. Fees vs. Savings

Some users express frustration that the fees (up to 25% of the total enrolled debt) eat into the savings negotiated. In 2026, the IRS still considers "forgiven debt" over $600 as taxable income. Many clients complain that after paying Freedom’s fees and the IRS's taxes, their total "savings" were much lower than the "50% reduction" advertised.

3. Creditor Refusal to Negotiate

Not all creditors play ball. Major lenders like Chase or Discover have historically been hesitant to work with third-party settlement firms. Complaints often highlight situations where a client spent months saving into a dedicated account only to find their largest creditor refused to negotiate, sometimes leading to a lawsuit against the consumer.

Historical Context: The $25 Million Lawsuit

To understand the 2026 reputation of Freedom Debt Relief, one must look back at its 2019 settlement with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB).

The CFPB alleged that the company:

Charged fees even when it hadn't actually settled the debt.
Misled consumers about its ability to negotiate with certain major creditors.
Failed to inform consumers of their right to withdraw their funds at any time.

Freedom Debt Relief paid $20 million in restitution to affected consumers and a $5 million civil penalty. Since then, the company has significantly increased its transparency and now offers a "Program Guarantee" where they refund fees if the total settlement cost exceeds the original debt.

Is Freedom Debt Relief Legit in 2026?

Yes, Freedom Debt Relief is a legitimate company. In early 2026, they were recognized by USA Today as one of "America’s Best Customer Service" providers for financial services. They are not a "scam," but they are a high-risk, high-reward financial strategy.

The Pros:

Professional Negotiation: They have the data and relationships to secure settlements that individuals might struggle to get on their own.
Legal Partner Network: In 2026, FDR provides access to legal help if a creditor decides to sue you during the program—a major upgrade from previous years.
Consolidated Payment: You make one monthly deposit rather than managing multiple credit card minimums.

The Cons:

No Guarantee: They cannot force a creditor to settle.
Legal Risk: You can still be sued for non-payment while in the program.
Long-term Credit Damage: Settled accounts remain on your credit report for seven years.

Comparing Alternatives: Is There a Better Way?

Before acting on a Freedom Debt Relief offer, consider these three alternatives:

Final Verdict: Should You Use Freedom Debt Relief?

Freedom Debt Relief is best for consumers who are already "drowning"—meaning they are already missing payments, have no path to paying off the principal, and want to avoid the legal "stigma" of bankruptcy.

If you have a credit score above 650 and are still making your minimum payments, the Freedom Debt Relief complaints regarding credit destruction should be a major red flag. In that case, a consolidation loan or a non-profit credit counseling agency is likely a better fit.

How to Minimize Risks:

Read the Fine Print: Ensure you understand the 15-25% fee structure.
Ask About Your Creditors: Specifically ask if your lenders (e.g., American Express or Chase) are currently negotiating with FDR.
Check the State Availability: Ensure they are licensed to operate in your specific U.S. state, as some states have stricter consumer protection laws that limit their services.